Ask HN: Will you be interested in Beta Testing Hacker News ios client I have created a hacker news iOS client. * It uses the Hacker News API. * You can upvote, follow and comment on stories / comments * Receive notifications as stories/comments you follow update If Yes, Please sign up for the beta by visiting: http://karanjude.github.io/hnbuzz/ |
The aesthetics doesn't match the standards introduced by Apple, nor does it match the quality of apps you're competing with.
There is an obvious lack of consistency, concerning icons, colors, margins, etc. It seems like it has not been polished in any way.
Here are specific design decisions that I don't agree with in your application:
- Why is the title of your pages black while icons are black?
- Why is the overscroll color gray?
- Why is there a padding/margin at the left of items that reveal that gray background?
- Why alternate the colors of the items?
- The right side of the title of items is cut.
- Every time I refresh the items, a dark overlay is added (and never gets removed)
- The horizontal swiping interactions between the side menu, the sliding to reveal comments and the fact that the content of an item itself scrolls, make these interactions difficult to predict and non-intuitive.
- Why is the HN logo different when you're in the item details?
- Why is the comment icon different in the details?
I'm sorry, there are just too many things wrong with this app. I lack the patience to go through every issue, and I'm now convinced that it's not worth the trouble.
If you ever want people to use your software, seek the help of a person that understands design.