Ask HN: Dropbox for source control Does anyone currently use Dropbox for source control instead of GitHub, etc? What are the pros and cons? |
Ask HN: Dropbox for source control Does anyone currently use Dropbox for source control instead of GitHub, etc? What are the pros and cons? |
A set of backup snapshots is not the same as source control. Your source control history is a story you tell about your code. Each commit is an important event, encapsulated on its own, with a person to blame and a text description and a definite date. Whereas a history of file changes is just a history of file changes.
The other point to make is that there is only one timeline of file changes. That is far too one-dimensional for code development. You need the ability to branch.
Using Dropbox for source control is like publishing an hour-by-hour activity log and claiming it's your autobiography:
9 am: Typing. Still breathing.
10am: Typing. Still breathing.
11am: walking to lunch, breathing faster
noon: eating.
1pm: typing. Still breathing.
You want a system that tracks the deliberately edited, important points of the story. You also want backups, of course, but they don't accomplish the same thing.It may be adequate protection from code loss, but does it enable you to work in a team?