Ask HN: Would appreciate any feedback on our site's home page design

2 points by bdmorgan 15 years ago | 4 comments

I'm working with some top-notch developers on a new football site (http://www.onsidekick.com) that will launch on June 1. The good news is we've built a good, solid site. The maybe-not-so-good news is none of us are great designers...we each know enough to be dangerous. Where that has taken us is this:

http://beta.onsidekick.com/content/images/screenshot.png

That's the home page design at the moment...I'd appreciate any honest/brutal feedback from some good designers, particularly anything with some actionable thoughts. If you have any questions, post them here and I'll check back in.

rudasn 15 years ago |

I looked it for about five minutes and still have no clue what this is about. Can you explain a bit more?

bdmorgan 15 years ago | |

It's a new online community for NFL and college football fans. We have a team of writers producing original content daily, as well as integration with 1000+ RSS and Twitter feeds from the football world. Members can follow any topics they wish - to be added to their own personal "stream" of information - and they can also set their interest level in each topic. Essentially, we're trying to build a true Web 2.0 football site that goes beyond 90's era message boards. The home page, in particular, has been tough for us because we want to highlight our original content but also make members aware of the various streams/communities on the site for each team, player, etc.

bdmorgan 15 years ago | |

.....although the fact that you say you've looked at it and have no clue what it's about may be my first indication that we still have some work to do :-)

profitbaron 15 years ago |

Clickable: http://www.onsidekick.com and http://beta.onsidekick.com/content/images/screenshot.png