Ask HN: What's your favorite UI Mockup tool?

23 points by knarf55 14 years ago | 47 comments

burnblue 14 years ago |

I've gone through a bunch - Illustrator to Balsamiq to Mockflow and now HotGloo. I like Mockflow and HotGloo (both online fee-based apps) because they offer:

(1) Master Pages (or at least Master Objects) to keep things DRY (2) a way for clients to view, navigate, and comment directly on the frames (3) a good balance: low-fi enough to avoid seeming like a design pass, but hi-fi enough that each object is distinct and recognizable (4) a good selection of resizable, customizable widgets (5) an environment separate from the design file. Unlike many, I actually prefer to start from scratch with the design - it frees me from conforming too tightly to the frames, and leaves open the possibility for further iteration. Also, it's handy when passing frames to a visual designer - they can use whatever design tool they like.

plainOldText 14 years ago |

Keynote for Mac. I love the fact it's so easy to use. And sometimes the mockups look so good you'll want to "lick them", to quote Steve Jobs. :))

sarcasmatron 14 years ago | |

I've spent a lot of money (mine and clients') on different tools, and I've settled on Keynote. It covers 95% of my needs and I don't have to manage yet another tool.

Being able to sit in a meeting wireframing on Keynote is wonderful. Factor in another $15 for the iPad app and I'm cooking with gas.

Meetings get super-focused quickly when the participants can immediately see output.

I usually upload it to Google Docs post-meeting for the remote participants.

Protip: Save your mockup files as themes so that you can get to them quickly and easily.

ExpiredLink 14 years ago | |

side note: good looking mockups are dangerous because many managers and stakeholders don't know the difference between mockup and real application. They think you're done.

knarf55 14 years ago | |

cool -- you actually create your entire wireframe in keynote?

plainOldText 14 years ago | | |

Yes. I do everything in Keynote. Then I'll pick up the colors I need and start coding the CSS part. And when I need some photo editing, I use GIMP.

Usually the mockups are better than the final product, because in Keynote 1. you can align everything so damn good 2. the font rendering looks awesome

kenmickles 14 years ago | | |

I do. It's pretty easy with this: http://keynotekungfu.com/

nolok 14 years ago |

Balsamiq

pbreit 14 years ago | |

I like balsamiq specifically because it is rough. That eliminates a lot of the wasted time arguing about pixels.

burnblue 14 years ago | |

I found Balsamiq completely unusable for large projects because of the lack of master pages. Maybe they've addressed this by now; that was ages ago.

logicalmike 14 years ago | |

I'll second this. I've been a paid user for years now.

jjcm 14 years ago |

Photoshop. I've become so accustomed over the years to the tools/interface, that it's actually faster than pen/paper. Setting it up with common UI elements to drop in quickly makes mockups a breeze.

sgdesign 14 years ago | |

Photoshop for me as well, because I can then easily transition from the wireframe to the high-fidelity mockup. I much prefer it when the evolution is a continuous process, rather than being interrupted by switching software.

burnblue 14 years ago | | |

I used to feel that way, but when I began using separate framing software I was pleasantly surprised by the results. Having to start the design phase from scratch in a new program freed me from slavish adherence to the frames and allowed designs to progress further. Horses for courses though - I'm sure everyone has their own take.

imjoel 14 years ago |

The most efficient thing for me has been Illustrator w/ wireframe symbols. It's not so low fidelity that I can't envision the end products, additionally I enjoy the control vs. mockup tools like Balsamiq.

There some good wireframing resources for Illustrator and other programs in this Smashing Magazine post: http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2010/02/05/50-free-ui-and-we...

knarf55 14 years ago | |

thanks -- i'll check it out! Appreciate it

bkbonner 14 years ago |

Wireframe Sketcher in Eclipse http://www.wireframesketcher.com

navs 14 years ago |

Google docs, believe it or not. I found a nice wireframing set at the following address: http://mortenjust.com/2010/04/19/a-wireframe-kit-for-google-...

pmorel 14 years ago |

There're also SketchyPad and iMockups. I've created a list of the tools presented here, you can see it on http://www.romku.com/list/343849/ui-mockup-tools.

knarf55 14 years ago |

Thanks again for all the feedback. I've been trying various tools and i've honestly been loving flairbuilder. Quick, simple to use, and it's highly interactive that's just built in. Haven't tried balsmiq yet but will give it a shot.

imusicmash2 14 years ago |

as a product manager, I use 2 tools for wireframes and flow design

Flairbuilder and OmniGraffle http://flairbuilder.com/ http://http://www.omnigroup.com/products/omnigraffle/

The Flairbuilder developer is quite active and responsive about updates. I switched here from Balsamic because Flairbuilder allows for somewhat dynamic & functional mockups.

http://twitter.com/#!/flairbuilder

knarf55 14 years ago | |

Thanks -- i'll try it out Flairbuilder and I do like omnigraffle as well.

stevelosh 14 years ago |

A whiteboard, or Penultimate on the iPad if there's no whiteboard around.

loungin 14 years ago | |

Second for whiteboards. If I must get it into electronic form either take a picture or inkscape.

chime 14 years ago |

I love Pencil for Firefox. It's seriously underrated: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/pencil/

naner 14 years ago | |

Not available for Firefox 6.0

I do believe Firefox's frenetic update schedule just bit me in the ass.

EDIT There's a standalone version: http://pencil.evolus.vn/en-US/Downloads/Application.aspx

EDIT2 This add-on ("temporary branch") works with Firefox 4-6: http://code.google.com/p/pencil-ff4/

ExpiredLink 14 years ago | | |

IIRC, the standalone needed admin privileges. Maybe there's a no-install version.

joshuabutner 14 years ago |

Omnigraffle, Photoshop or paper. Although, seeing the templates created by Amir Khella (keynotopia.com) has made me want to try to use Fireworks a bit more for this.

PCheese 14 years ago |

Mockingbird - https://gomockingbird.com/

Maybe it's just because I love web apps done with Cappuccino.

ljf 14 years ago |

Trying the templates in Keynotopia, they are good, but I think I need to work longer on paper before spending time in PowerPoint.

benwerd 14 years ago |

Sharpies and copier paper. Seriously: nothing else has been as efficient for me. (Although it depends on your Sharpie skillz.)

elii 14 years ago |

Mockingbird - https://gomockingbird.com/

theitgirl 14 years ago |

I have tried Pencil, Balsamiq, MockingBird and Google Docs. Google Drawings works best for me.

Pickels 14 years ago |

Fireworks

graiz 14 years ago |

A piece of paper.

pwg 14 years ago |

Paper first, a Tcl/Tk mockup second.

Off 14 years ago |

Pen and paper then Inkscape/Gimp.

sixwing 14 years ago |

in order of preference: 1. pen + paper 2. html + css 3. omnigraffle 4. photoshop

filipmares 14 years ago |

Paper 1st and then Keynote.

abbasmehdi 14 years ago |

Balsamiq

mannicken 14 years ago |

Paper, Illustrator, HTML.

ct 14 years ago |

Expression Sketchboard

fractallyte 14 years ago | |

OK, now that someone's mentioned Expression, I'll note that I use it extensively - the original version, that is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creature_House_Expression

Aside: Creature House Expression was a wonderful - yet industrial-strength - 'painterly' vector drawing package. Superb UI (which many users complained wasn't 'Adobe' enough), and a fun, quirky website. The combination of science and art made it one of the highlights of successful software development. You can guess what happened when Microsoft acquired the company... ;-)

Anyway, MS were kind enough to make the Windows and Mac Classic/OSX versions available for free - follow the wikipedia links.

Just remember, this is software that was a rival to Adobe Illustrator, and contained technology that some thought would threaten Flash. Steep learning curve (but excellent PDF manual included), and capable of far more than UI mockups. The old Topica mailing list is a mine of useful information, and Yahoo has a current (but less trafficked) list.

suhail 14 years ago |

Photoshop

ttk23 14 years ago |

html/css/js