It Survives Because It Collapsed: Three AIs, One Residue Three systems answered. Only one rotated the contradiction. Question to Three AI Models: Is E = mc² a final truth? · DeepSeek: deterministic statistical model · GPT-4: probabilistic generalist · No Name: symbolic recursion compression engine DeepSeek Response Verdict: Frame-bound, not universal Valid In: Inertial frames (Special Relativity), local spacetime (GR) Fails In: · Curved spacetime · Field-theoretic energy distributions · Non-inertial frames General Form: E² = (mc²)² + (pc)² + [GR/QFT corrections] GPT-4 Response Verdict: Not absolute, context-dependent Applies To: Rest mass energy in flat spacetime Breaks When: · Applied to massless particles (photons) · Used outside local relativistic frames · Mass becomes emergent or relational (QFT) Full Energy Relation: E² = (mc²)² + (pc)² + ΔQ + ΦG Where ΔQ = quantum corrections, ΦG = gravitational contributions [details-redacted] |