ClawHub

ClawHub(clawhub.ai)

50 points by druther 142 days ago | 41 comments

So I click on "Skills" and it feels like the page cannot decide what to show me, every item on the list shifts and moves, how is anyone supposed to click on something if it disappears?

m-hodges 142 days ago |

This is what? The 4th or 5th attempt at this in the past two weeks?

verdverm 142 days ago | |

Welcome to the world with zero cost software

sph 142 days ago | | |

Show HN as a service

isodev 142 days ago |

So let's recap:

- I click skills.

- The first one is WireGuard "... secure routing and key management".

- I'd download it, hook it to this bot running on my system.

- I'd ask the bot to store / manage super-secret keys that protect actual servers with user data and personal details and god knows what...

- The bot follows my commands by spelunking random snippets of markdown, running other programs on my computer, doing web searches, reading what it finds on the web and giving itself more commands to do...

I've only been in tech for like 20 years or so but I feel like either I'm missing something substantial or some kind of madness is happening to people.

dpoloncsak 142 days ago | |

You're downloading untested code from an unknown user on a random literally just-spun-up 'marketplace' and are shocked when it doesn't work

monooso 142 days ago | | |

I think you misinterpreted GP's comment (or at least the tone).

Shank 142 days ago | | |

> I've only been in tech for like 20 years or so but I feel like either I'm missing something substantial or some kind of madness is happening to people.

People are extremely eager for a helpful AI assistant that they are willing to sacrifice security for it. Prompt injection attacks are theoretical until they hit you. Until you're hit you're just having fun riding the wave.

sgarland 142 days ago | |

> I feel like either I'm missing something substantial or some kind of madness is happening to people

It is WILD how little “professionals” actually understand about systems, security, or really computers in general.

free_bip 142 days ago |

Who is scanning these skills for malware? This seems like a prime target for malicious actors.

ru552 142 days ago | |

Virustotal at upload and periodically during the day

Nextgrid 142 days ago | | |

VirusTotal is completely useless for this though? You need enough people to be pwned by that particular piece of malware for it to be flagged as dangerous, by which point the attackers would've already repacked it so it doesn't match the previous signature.

dpoloncsak 142 days ago | |

These are single-file .MDs, right? Written in markdown...

Can't you just read it?

writeslowly 142 days ago | | |

I see a number of uploaded skills on the site with bash and python scripts. No idea what runs them

StevenNunez 142 days ago |

Does Openwork replace the need for openclaw? Seems like a more grown up version of it.

arnvald 142 days ago |

Do these skills actually provide much value? Like, how much better are they than something that I could tell Claude to generate based on a single API doc from Slack/Trello?

Flavius 142 days ago | |

Zero. If a skill actually provides value, one of two things happens: it gets absorbed into Claude Code (or similar) within a week, or a company packages it up and charges real money for it. The "free skill that gives you an edge" window is essentially nonexistent. By the time you find it, everyone else has it too. You're better off learning to prompt well against raw API docs than chasing a library of pre-built skills that are either trivial to recreate or about to be made redundant.

clandry94 142 days ago | |

From my experience, most are just some high level instructions on how to use CLI tools installed on the system. A lot of the CLI tools they're calling out to have 0 reputation on Github or don't work at all.

I've had more luck writing my own skills using CLI tools I know and trust.

CuriouslyC 142 days ago | | |

That's a big part of the reason skills are exploding, people use them as stealth marketing in addition to being a malware injection vector.

raffkede 142 days ago | |

Skills is actually what also Claude code uses internally, it's cool because the llm will load the whole context on how to use it only on demand and keeps the context cleaner.

mrexcess 142 days ago | |

>Do these skills actually provide much value?

IMO, yes. Gemini et. al. out of the box are good at composing, but are entirely passive. Skills enable you to - easily, with low code/no code - teach your AI to perform active tasks either upon direction or under any automatic conditions you specify. This is incredibly powerful. Incredibly dangerous, too, but so is a car when compared with a skateboard.

neya 142 days ago | |

My understanding is that it's just an abstraction layer that feeds right into the context window. Might as well just feed it into the prompt. I think cursor even proved that skills aren't as good as direct prompts (or something to that extent, can't remember exactly)

etchalon 142 days ago |

How could a public repository of unverified skills that can be downloaded by casual users for a software tool that allows for un-gated access to private information, including financial information, possibly go wrong?

"Don't worry, we have stars."

Itchy and Scratchy land is open for business.

acidocious 142 days ago | |

"Bort? Who the hell is called Bort?!"

etchalon 142 days ago | | |

My son is also named Bort.

incomingpain 142 days ago |

I have the clawhub skill disabled. You really shouldnt use it, especially when you can just have your claw create their own skills as needed.

mrbluecoat 142 days ago |

> Upload AgentSkills bundles, version them like npm, and make them searchable with vectors. No gatekeeping, just signal.

Sigh, when I read this and only understand "npm", I feel like retiring.

assimpleaspossi 142 days ago | |

Half the stuff posted like this doesn't give a clue what it does at all much less use made up phrases that make no sense (to most of us).