Who is done with code reviews?

2 points by javier_e06 76 days ago | 3 comments

Why do we have code reviews? AI might not be behind at writing code from scratch but AI is far superior at reviewing code changes.

drewbitt 76 days ago |

I have not seen any AI review do codebase conventions consistently well. Scenarios like - the code may be valid, but it doesn't use our library for x feature, or in FE it isn't using the new component / styling, etc. Enterprise things. Once someone figures that out it's nearly solved except when requiring undocumented context IMO

Trickery5837 76 days ago |

I actually do more code reviews, because it's the person that signs the commit that is responsible for the code, not the AI

byzkhan 76 days ago |

Yep. Big reason why we are working on making Macroscope.com move to auto approving and merging PRs