Ask HN: Is there a secret satellite war?

3 points by _justinfunk 54 days ago | 4 comments

Are "our enemies" launchings space assets that eat/wound/hijack/destroy our space assets? Do "we" launch space assets that eat/wound/hijack/destroy "our enemies" space assets?

Since all these assets are top-secret on both sides, it seems like it could be a whole dimension of war that I've never considered could be actively underway.

verdverm 54 days ago |

Most satellites are tracked outside of the controlling entities. See the various posts over the years tracking DARPA experimental long-term flight and return to earth vehicles. There have been some about Russian satellites having encounters with other satellites.

This is to say, if there was something significant going on, there's a very good chance it will be known.

wmf 54 days ago |

It's more of a cold war because the assets are being put in place but they aren't being used in anger. There are satellites taking pictures of other satellites. There are anti-satellite missiles. Satellite capture/grappling mechanisms are being tested. We don't know what the X-37B is doing but it could capture small satellites and return them to Earth. Orbital drop pods and orbit-to-ground missiles are being developed. This is all unclassified so there could be more.

Bender 54 days ago |

If they are being bricked nobody outside of the military or corporations using them will know. Once satellites are being de-orbited you will know. They make a nifty light show on the way down that varies based on mass and type of materials used. I think one is supposed to make a wish any time that happens.

FrankWilhoit 54 days ago |

If so, it would manifest as sabotage of satellite launches. There may, indeed, have been some of that down the years.