You Don't Love Systemd Timers Enough(blog.tjll.net) |
You Don't Love Systemd Timers Enough(blog.tjll.net) |
> Ambiguous $PATH settings make cron script execution difficult to predict.
What makes you say that? You can set the PATH right in the crontab. Is that harder to "predict" than it being set in /etc/bashrc, ~/.bashrc, ~/.profile, ~/.bash_profile, /etc/systemd/…, or wherever else?
> You might feel cool knowing the scheduling grammar by heart
I've used Linux since 1994 and I don't know it by heart. But luckily it's pre-printed in the crontab as comments:
# For more information see the manual pages of crontab(5) and cron(8)
#
# m h dom mon dow command
The rest of the complaints, sure. Next time I need a cronjob, I'll try it out.
That is not a fair summarization of their point because that is not the grammar. There's commas, slashes, asterisks, combinations, and then if you want randomization you need to put it in the command itself because cron can't do it. (Some crons can, but it's not a general capability of cron.) Writing a non-trivial cron spec is not easy.
That does require you to still know what the default environment is, but it is a mostly completely clean environment, without any influence from any shell.
I'd have to concur that I agree this is an advantage of systemd.
If nothing else, maybe it could be some kid's high school science fair project idea.
It sat unused and powered off for a couple of years after he passed, until I needed a color print.
Didn't do anything but hook it up to power and print. Took about 1/5 of a page until all colors were back in action, after that it printed about 20 pages flawlessly.
And I printed a lot of photos, notes, documents, etc
Btw this is my repo for the backup automation: https://github.com/gchamon/borg-automated-backups
To do this at the user level, you can add something like "@hourly anacron -t /path/to/anacrontab -S /path/to/spooldir" to the user's crontab, though I've never tried this.
Many cron implementations have a similar mechanism.
This isn't the same as with systemd timer because timer lets you specify when you want to run your service exactly and will fallback to running when the system comes online. With @hourly I lose this control and multiple machines could potentially trigger backups at the same time, hogging the physical hard drives and the network.
> runs the service as soons as the system is available.
cron has the @reboot option which I use for a few scripts and works great.
Not an option either, because if I reboot two machines and the backup starts in both of them it'll cripple my NAS
I've noticed more and more open source projects recommending timers as a deployment method and I think that's great!
I will admit thought, timers are up there in terms of being the clunkiest systemd unit type to use on a regular basis. I get why they're split up into two files and require different start vs enable syntax's, but man sometimes I just want to create a file that runs a script and be done with it.
Like imagine trying to explain systemd timers and services and unit files to a beginner.
I think it's... easier? Like "systemd is the place where your system manages all the processes it needs to run. Part of those processes can be run on a schedule, or on a timer, and you define them using this simple text file".
Yet there's always something new to learn and actually consider as another useful tool.
Which makes it nice to distribute a tool for NixOS so that it can lean into systemd instead of as some bolted-on afterthought.
Makes me wonder what you'd do if you were distributing a lifecycle-heavy tool for Linux users in general since systemd isn't ubiquitous.
I use a systemd timer to run a monthly scrub for my btrfs pool. Kinda cool how you can do increasingly useful things like skip the next scheduled event if the user initiates a scrub, do or don't accumulate tasks if you have a monthly task but the machine was offline for 6 months -- or fold them into a single task, etc.
systemd.services.sync-recyclarr = {
serviceConfig.Type = "oneshot";
path = [ pkgs.podman ];
script = ''
podman exec -it recyclarr recyclarr sync radarr
podman exec -it recyclarr recyclarr sync sonarr
'';
};
systemd.timers.sync-recyclarr = {
timerConfig = {
OnCalendar = "daily";
Persistent = true;
Unit = "sync-recyclarr.service";
};
partOf = [ "sync-recyclarr.service" ];
requires = [ "podman-recyclarr.service" ];
wantedBy = [ "timers.target" ];
};The problem I have found is that nixos doesn't seem to pickup and run systemd timers and services placed into the ~/.config/systems/user folder and additionally things like WantedBy=default.target have no effect.
So after I restart all my services manually on reboot I agree, systems timers are cool.
a) It is way nicer and you get decent validation at build time
b) A LLM can port units over if the need arises; it’s a very light abstraction around systemd syntax
c) I personally don’t see how I would ever move to another distro :)
Oh but it won't appear in the timer-specific logs, I guess...
I am dealing with mostly non systemd system: BSD, Alpine, termux On BSD anacron works well, but I do not why I am always running into problems with the cronie anacron implementation. And it is very hard to debug.
I would really like a simple modern cron/anacron alternative.
Cronicle looked cool but it is node.js, a bit heavy and being replace now by their new product called xyOps anyway.
[Service]
Type=oneshot
WorkingDirectory={{ home }}/current/
Environment=RAILS_ENV=production
ExecStart=/bin/sh -lc "bin/db-backup --verbose"
Over all I think Systemd get way to much criticism. You don't have to use all the parts, but if you care to go through the documentation you'll find interesting features such as journald log-shipping and systemd-machined which can manage containers and VMs.
If I never recall hacking in ulimit calls in the top of buggy shell scripts for crappy old services that done respect pam_limits it won’t be soon enough.
Could have been YAML.
Could have been XML.
It's a shame docker never supported it. I feel like if they had got on board all those years ago there would be broad support across the software ecosystem for it and we wouldn't need half of these complicated iptables rules and proxies and service mesh. It would be a step towards a capability based system.
It would also make it much simpler to make good GUI editors for the files instead of the Notepad approach most unix config files take.
Could have been XML Property Lists.
ducks
CPU speeds have increased & and i/o latency has decreased so much since then that startup times are generally imperceptible, so the pendulum has swung back to favouring socket activation.
The anti-systemd "traditionalists" never seem to acknowledge that history, though!
https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/latest/syst...
XML is that wonderful format that gave us vulnerabilities like death by million laughs, up to a certain moment, you could MitM DTDs, and a whole slew of everything-XML stuff back when XML was like AI is today, none of which I miss today.
Oh, and remember times when programmers would argue whether argument order in XML files should be significant or not?
But XML books with their idealized XML future description did give me the same warm fuzzies as some intricate clockwork mechanism to a Victorian geek.
That isn't something I'd want to happen, it sounds like it creates a potential queue of scripts that will flood the system on start, if it works the way you described.
I prefer the deterministic behavior of cron, the script will run when it is specified to run, as you said earlier, as long as the system is running; and as I stated in a separate comment, it will run @reboot if I need it to run then.
> With @hourly I lose this control and multiple machines could potentially trigger backups at the same time
Then don't use @hourly, use staggered times, it's very easy.
This isn't what happens. If you leave it offline for days it'll only trigger the service only a single time.
[Service]
Type = oneshot
WorkingDirectory = %h/current/
Environment = RAILS_ENV=production
ExecStart = /bin/sh -lc "bin/db-backup --verbose"I find myself doing this sort of thing all the time..