Monthly upgrades are painless. Once a year the major versions (18 to 19, for example) bump external dependencies and we need about an hour on it.
I've been using GitHub for other projects and for the life of me I can't see a single area where its better. Actions is worse without versioned and self documenting components, there's no concept of a project hierarchy or inherited permissions, even simple things like setting up deploy keys are more annoying than they need to be.
I can't speak for GitLab.com - I've never used it.
I also enjoy Gitlab as a platform. It's got everything, good board, good repo, good issues, good CI, extremely good registries. It's got the equivalent of gists and pages... It a better product all things considered.
GitHub just wins because of popularity. It's WordPress all over again, the thing people use because it's a thing people use.
Recently they changed the issues list, and it just got worse
They changed the merge request list to be way too smart, making assumptions about user's workflows
To me it feels like they have way too many engineers looking for things to solve that arent really problems
The CI system is great though
Running it self hosted is also generally without any problems - although they just broke my upgrade to 19 because they decided to remove mattermost
Triggering github actions manually is way, way cleaner. Also the pipeline configuration feels cleaner to me bit that might be personal preference more than anything else.. Otherwise I agree. =)
Our github->slack subscription breaks every few months, they never acknowledged it before. At this point we have a doc with the list of repos and settings, whenever someone notices that things are awfully quiet we just go through it and resubscribe.
Not 2 minutes later, a coworker sent a message saying they got a message: their repository messages couldn't be sent, because the user is no longer authorized. The coworker was worried that they might be fired.
Alas, this economy is a terrible time for one business's fuckups to cause worry about people being fired. That's a lot of stress, man!
If only it were measurable in dollars, then we could sue Microsoft for damages. Maybe then Microsoft might stop producing slop. Ahh, wait. Who am I kidding? No, of course that won't cause Microsoft to stop producing slop.
GitHub's reputation has been long overcooked and you are better off self-hosting and you would have better up time than GitHub.
Github is making engineers more productive by turning off distracting fake work tools
Everything has an expiration date it seems. I assumed I just missed a reminder email or message.
I blame the one who coined it -- for having created an entire career based on vibes, namely vibe driving, vibe neural networking, and finally vibe coding -- none of them work.
There was a trillion dollars pushing for them to quickly say it wasn’t.
*approximately 8% of the above quote has been adjusted to better reflect the impact of the Ai.
not both , please.
[0]: https://www.cnbc.com/2025/04/29/satya-nadella-says-as-much-a...
Utter degradation.