Exploring PDP-1 Lisp (1960)

Exploring PDP-1 Lisp (1960)(obsolescence.dev)

27 points by ozymandiax 2 hours ago | 14 comments

ozymandiax 1 hour ago |

I was wrong - it was not Peter Deutsch who ported Eliza to Lisp, it was Bernie Cossell at BBN (one of the famous IMP Guys a few years later!). And it is here:

https://github.com/jeffshrager/elizagen.org/tree/master/1966...

That makes a PDP-1 Lisp backport very tempting... amazing how ancient code comes back from presumed extinction.

ozymandiax 2 hours ago |

Written by Peter Deutsch, then a then-high school student on a tiny 4K (admittedly, 4K 18-bit words) machine. Amazingly usable - and lives on in the Python REPL concept.

Our PiDP-1 simulator on github lets you try it out on any Linux machine (not just a Raspberry PI): https://github.com/obsolescence/pidp1

Posting this in the hope that someone will feel triggered to backport Eliza, it was done in the 1960s but it's been lost :-)

AdieuToLogic 44 minutes ago | |

> Posting this in the hope that someone will feel triggered to backport Eliza, it was done in the 1960s but it's been lost :-)

When in doubt, there is always the option to implement Eliza in a Forth[0] embedded within a dish washing machine's firmware. It could converse about one's thoughts regarding pre-soak techniques. :-)

0 - https://www.forth.com/starting-forth/

blooalien 2 hours ago | |

> Posting this in the hope that someone will feel triggered to backport Eliza, it was done in the 1960s but it's been lost :-)

Some of us who remember actually playing with Eliza are absolutely amused by all the hype around LLMs (because it's so similar to the hype heard from "normies" who saw Eliza and thought we were "just around the corner from real AI"; The same folk who thought we'd all have a flying car in every garage by now, LOL!). Still really impressed by what LLMs actually can do though, despite them being not much closer to true "thinking machines". ;)

gwern 2 hours ago | | |

ELIZA has been refound: https://sites.google.com/view/elizaarchaeology/home

ozymandiax 2 hours ago | | |

When we visited some of the 1970s 'heros' of the MIT AI Lab, we were told the informal story behind SHRDLU, the AI living in a PDP-10 3D world. How this graphical AI triggered the first AI Summer --

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZGQcJVdjj8

-- and as it fell short of first impressions, perhaps the first winter too?

fsckboy 1 hour ago | |

>Posting this in the hope that someone will feel triggered to backport Eliza, it was done in the 1960s but it's been lost :-)

you can run eliza in emacs, just " M-X doctor " enter

ozymandiax 1 hour ago | | |

But we'd need to backport emacs to the PDP-1 then :-)

sourdecor 2 hours ago |

Kind of a non sequitur: I bought "The Genius of Lisp"[0] and it is not what I thought (a book entirely devoted to the history of Lisp - from MIT to Common Lisp and then to Clojure). Would anyone recommend another book?

[0]: https://www.amazon.com/Genius-Lisp-Cees-Groot/dp/1069886416/

ozymandiax 2 hours ago | |

The PDP-1 Lisp page has 4 rather good books linked as PDFs. Oh - but all on the earliest history of Lisp as well! That is not what you're looking for I think.