ZeroFS vs. Amazon S3 Files

31 points by cbrewster 4 hours ago | 10 comments

Author here. Thanks for posting this!

It’s been quite a ride building ZeroFS, and I’m happy to answer any questions.

chillfox 56 minutes ago | |

Thanks for building this, I am just about to give it ago with my self-hosted Garage cluster.

Does running `stat` against a file require pulling the whole file from s3, or can that be handled by the metadata?

Do you know what backup performance is like for something like borg/borgmatic or restic, especially on follow up runs where most files are just checked.

Is there any particular Redis/Valkey config you recommend when using it for `conditional_put`, or just default config?

Is there any chance for NFSv4 support?

pierrebarre 39 minutes ago | | |

Thanks!

stat doesn’t pull the file contents from S3; it only accesses the metadata tree, which is usually cached.

I haven’t benchmarked Borg or Restic specifically. Sequential writes can comfortably reach several Gbit/s. For follow-up runs, if they only stat unchanged files, that should stay entirely in metadata.

The default Redis/Valkey configuration should work fine for conditional_put. NFSv4 is unlikely for now. It would add a lot of surface area, and I’m pretty happy with where the 9P extensions are today.

hhthrowaway1230 1 hour ago |

I really want this, but it feels a little scary to trust all my files. I wouls like it if there was some contineous suite trying to corrupt the files and then see the failure cases!

pierrebarre 1 hour ago | |

That’s a fair concern. The closest thing right now is a deterministic simulation suite that injects storage faults and crashes at arbitrary points, then checks the recovered data against reference models. It runs hourly with fresh seeds.

CI also runs pjdfstest, xfstests, stress-ng, ZFS scrubs, and Jepsen crash/failover tests: https://github.com/Barre/ZeroFS#testing

ZeroFS is still pretty young as storage projects go, so I completely understand wanting to see it prove itself over time.

ahofmann 47 minutes ago | | |

Why the hell was this answer dead? I vouched for it, because I don't see what might be wrong with it.

Lucasoato 2 hours ago |

The article diagrams can’t be seen well if the device has the dark mode as default, just a suggestion for the author.

Opened with Safari in iOS

smartbit 48 minutes ago | |

I have the same in Brave on iOS: to see the the diagrams I need to turn of Night Mode.

ranger_danger 1 hour ago | |

I only saw one diagram but it is perfectly visible for me on the desktop.

hhthrowaway1230 1 hour ago |

Also would love to know how was we could iterate over the files. ie a bit how duckdb allows for paruet fikes scanning and reading would be nice to see how fast we can query the fs for ai/ml training workloads