Happy Anniversary WWW

Happy Anniversary WWW(jacquesmattheij.com)

52 points by bussetta 12 years ago | 12 comments

Well said, Jacques.

There are too many angry, ranty, sensationalist accounts of why online surveillance is A Bad Thing, and you put it in a calm & rational way.

I hope more people read this article and better understand the objections if they didn't already.

currywurst 12 years ago |

"It’s been a bit of a slow realization for me, but I don’t actually want to be safe, I’d rather be free and unsafe."

This, I believe, is the key tension in democracies. A majority of the constituents can be scared into compromises for "their security", not fully understanding what they are really giving up. A large number would rather "feel safe" than "feel free".

lutusp 12 years ago | |

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." -- Benjamin Franklin

sp332 12 years ago | | |

That's a much easier quote to throw around than "Live free or die: Death is not the worst of evils." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Live_Free_or_Die or maybe "What is to be done? The answer is easy. It has always been easy. Stop saying 'not in my name' and start saying 'over my dead body'. That's what we did. It works. Do it." http://wlcentral.org/node/2818

Datsundere 12 years ago | |

I disagree with that statement. It's possible that he hasn't lost someone close in any kind of traumatic event that makes him so optimistic about it. Human nature compels people to want revenge or hatred towards say the same (religious) groups that the "terrorists" were from. This is very evident post 9/11. People hated muslims, destroyed their properties and discriminated them.

I think it's not time to be so care free. We don't even understand the universe yet. Of course I don't want survellience, but there has to be a requirement for saftey, and yes if that means putting bad people behind bars and make society advance faster so that we can colonize other planets, and understand how everything works better. There needs to be more scientists and engineers not more thieves.

unionpivo 12 years ago | | |

Nobody has problem with putting bad guys into prisons. All civilized societies do this.

What I/we have a problem with is that everybody is treated as guilty, spied on etc.

This becomes even bigger problem when you consider that most governments consider anyone that is not with them to be their enemy. So in essence If you don't 100% agree and support government you are an enemy and then anything goes (spying, dronestrikes, ...).

Additionally I am not American, I don't even get a vote, but i am beeing spied on, and If I make to much fuzz them might decide to drone me. (As far as I know they haven't killed any EU citizens, but I doubt they would think twice). They also keep expanding who they go after, first it was just the Al Kaida and other terrorist, now its pretty much anyone USA doesn't like. So to put it bluntly I as a EU citizen am far more scared of USA than Al Kaida.

Datsundere 12 years ago | | |

of course, hide and downvote without giving an argument. This is not different from the freedom you want oh wait

oskarth 12 years ago | |

It's also a weak form of stating the difference between the two possibilities.

In practice, "safe" often means "safe" and a slight possibility of being very unsafe (say, by being labelled a terrorist). Not to mention the (slight? inevitable?) possibility of future major abuse a la <pick-your-own-favourite-despot>.

tosbourn 12 years ago |

Obligatory link to http://howoldistheinter.net/

lazugod 12 years ago |

Does the Internet Archive project collect emails or cross any privacy lines? Will future Archive members be as benevolent?

(Should I go read the Archive's website and find out for myself? Probably yes.)

jacquesm 12 years ago | |

They don't collect email because that's behind a password protected access if it is web driven and presumably imap or pop if it isn't. So your emails are not stored by the IA.

I don't speak on behalf of the archive nor am I in any way associated with it but from a technical point of view the archive crawlers simply do not have access to your emails.

See the faq for lots more information:

http://archive.org/about/faqs.php