White House review panel proposes curbs on some NSA programs

White House review panel proposes curbs on some NSA programs(chicagotribune.com)

16 points by hojoff79 12 years ago | 3 comments

PaulAJ 12 years ago |

I'm sorry, but its irrelevant. If it tells us that the NSA has turned cyberspace into a giant panopticon, then we already know that. If it tells us that the NSA has been responsibly limiting its surveillance to overseas targets known to be working against the USA, then we know its lying.

TrainedMonkey 12 years ago | |

I am sorry, but you are incorrect. This is quite relevant for at least two reasons:

1. This is marked change of course coming from white house. Previously there was a push to maintain status quo.

2. Due to Snowden we already know quite a bit about surveillance practices. Based on that report we can judge how many things NSA "abstracts" from white house and call them out on it.

salient 12 years ago | | |

> This is marked change of course coming from white house

Is it really? The White House has already disagreed with one of the major changes proposed by this panel (which overall, I still think they are pretty limited, and don't go far enough) - separating NSA from the US Cyber Command.

I also care less about what the White House/Obama promises to change (not our first rodeo with this, is it?), and more about what Congress is going to change and what's going to make explicitly illegal.