PHP Framework CodeIgniter Has a New Home

PHP Framework CodeIgniter Has a New Home(ellislab.com)

40 points by saadazzz 11 years ago | 7 comments

pan69 11 years ago |

I'm glad CI has a new home. For many in the PHP community is was their first MVC framework.

Although I wish BCIT all the best I'd wish it would have been picked up by WordPress instead. WordPress is great but it's really showing its age and it could do with a major overhaul. If WordPress would have adopted CI, bring it up to scratch with modern PHP development (Composer, PSR, component oriented, etc.) and build the next generation of WordPress (5.0?) on top of that, I think would have been beneficial to the greater community.

Edit: However, that might conflict with whatever Ellis labs is doing these days..

arbuge 11 years ago |

Great to hear it has a new home. CI has been a good friend for several years - I still use it daily. It will be interesting to see if BCIT can bring it up to par with modern PHP frameworks like Laravel & Symfony 2.

rreynier 11 years ago |

I used to love Codeigniter, but recently have been introduced to testing, testing and more testing. Codeigniter makes testing near IMPOSSIBLE unless you do some core system hacks. And even then, stubs, dependencies, fixtures.. don't even think about it. Unfortunately to make Codeigniter a fully testable framework, they will have fundamentally rewrite the whole thing. And I do think this has become more and more of a core requirement for modern frameworks.

That being said, I suppose at the end of the day, Codeigniter is still blazing fast and so incredibly easy to introduce to a newer developer. Maybe it will always have a place, and if so, I wish BCIT best of luck!

meigwilym 11 years ago |

Whilst I'm pleased that CI will not die an unmaintained death, I do wonder if it will be worth putting in the work to modernize the framework.

Symfony2 and others are now so much more ahead of CI. Composer and PSR-x standards make developing in PHP much more of a programming rather than scripting experience, and CI still feels closer to the latter.

On the other hand, I learnt much from CI when I first started MVC and OO development, so best of luck to BCIT.

benbristow 11 years ago |

CodeIgniter is great. The first MVC PHP framework I learnt to use.

Started to move over to Laravel now since that's where 'all the cool kids' are heading.

lukifer 11 years ago | |

I've also moved over to Laravel for the most part, but I like the minimalism of CodeIgniter, and still use it occasionally. It's actually to CI's advantage that it has grown so conservatively: it's still fast, secure, reliable, quick to deploy and upgrade, and there's not much to learn when coming back after years of absence.

(My only real gripe has been the lack of a good Model base class, which led me to roll my own: https://github.com/lukifer/TheMissingModel)

Best of luck to BCIT, I hope they keep building on CI's core strengths and resist the temptation to make radical changes.

meigwilym 11 years ago | | |

Nice work. It's also worth checking out Jamie Rumbelow's MY_Model

https://github.com/jamierumbelow/codeigniter-base-model