16:[[22534520,{"by":"flippyhead","descendants":247,"id":22534520,"kids":[22535390,22535166,22536316,22535274,22535268,22535762,22535414,22535142,22536880,22535611,22537177,22537890,22535392,22534561,22535768,22535121,22536404,22535217,22535302,22535747,22535224,22535755,22536718,22535155,22535199,22535737,22535133,22535674,22534535,22535666,22535254,22536201,22536387,22536353,22534833,22535558,22575929,22539710,22535964,22535147,22537823,22537749,22535290,22538535,22536658,22601711,22601687,22543550,22541315,22539167,22536660,22541807,22536156,22538497,22546740,22536788,22545609,22535997,22535601,22541597,22534649,22535197,22554374,22536176,22535785,22538280,22558594,22537083,22598967,22537747,22536220,22537425,22535442,22536510,22536002,22547638,22537603,22535499,22540014,22535519,22536248,22536666,22537619,22537118,22539640,22545254,22536414,22538872,22536101,22537349,22535849,22535634,22536969,22535262,22535249],"score":274,"text":"My company of ~25 people needs to manage access to probably ~100 services our employees use everyday and I assume some kind of password manager which I can centrally manage is the way to go.

I often hear things on here about products that claim to be secure but aren't -- what password manager is considered reliable and secure? Which do you use?

Thank you!","time":1583839729,"title":"Ask HN: What's the best corporate password manager?","type":"story"}],[22472080,{"by":"kimhindart","descendants":3,"id":22472080,"kids":[22474065,22474306,22473707],"score":26,"time":1583213613,"title":"The world faces an air pollution 'pandemic'","type":"story","url":"https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2020-03/esoc-twf022720.php"}],[22288526,{"by":"pradeepl","descendants":61,"id":22288526,"kids":[22301690,22299304,22299380,22303673,22300248,22313550,22305701,22303457,22305789,22303961,22303173],"score":160,"time":1581337946,"title":"Event-Driven Architecture","type":"story","url":"https://pradeeploganathan.com/architecture/event-driven-architecture/"}],[21738802,{"by":"matt_d","descendants":197,"id":21738802,"kids":[21748421,21741120,21745822,21748956,21743691,21749137,21750441,21748624,21749348,21749273,21751672,21748695,21740862,21743699,21749056,21748559,21750671,21753380,21751741,21748489,21749032,21751651,21751210,21744740,21747911,21753731,21750635,21749539,21748057,21748573,21740987,21751335,21752434,21748199],"score":429,"time":1575843615,"title":"Why databases use ordered indexes but programming uses hash tables","type":"story","url":"https://www.evanjones.ca/ordered-vs-unordered-indexes.html"}],[17377347,{"by":"minimaxir","descendants":458,"id":17377347,"kids":[17377866,17377622,17377651,17377709,17377606,17378196,17378213,17378647,17378181,17377607,17380311,17377574,17377713,17377620,17378281,17378585,17377950,17380155,17380243,17378487,17377946,17378056,17379459,17377994,17378699,17377926,17378272,17379316,17378016,17379921,17378215,17384841,17379274,17380621,17377852,17378153,17378185,17377952,17380224,17380469,17380330,17382443,17381168,17377700,17379376,17378745,17382649,17377656,17377632,17380674,17380839,17378445,17379216,17378519,17378392,17378419,17378330,17380461,17380124,17377680,17378520,17377577,17378491],"score":682,"time":1529701545,"title":"Keyboard Service Program for MacBook and MacBook Pro","type":"story","url":"https://www.apple.com/support/keyboard-service-program-for-macbook-and-macbook-pro/"}],[16961723,{"by":"japhyr","descendants":19,"id":16961723,"kids":[16962018,16962610,16962007,16962211,16962269,16961735],"score":17,"text":"It's been interesting to read about the impact of GDPR on sites of all sizes and purposes. Let's say I have a site where people can write and share math problems. I have a simple policy stating that any problem that directly or indirectly harasses anyone or any group will be flagged and deleted, and that repeated behavior like this will lead to banning.

Say a user gets banned. They then ask me to remove all information about them from my site. Am I allowed to keep any information that would help me keep this person from starting this cycle all over again?

What impacts will GDPR, and other data retention policies like it, have on the issue of moderation?","time":1525118418,"title":"Ask HN: What does GDPR mean for banning users?","type":"story"}],[15601729,{"by":"whoishiring","descendants":1182,"id":15601729,"kids":[15602770,15602856,15601966,15602619,15602388,15604424,15601757,15601849,15604118,15603462,15603188,15607161,15602042,15602328,15602243,15601754,15602225,15606212,15602519,15602788,15606115,15602170,15604185,15601875,15603618,15601742,15604672,15605619,15606360,15604252,15603360,15604677,15604527,15605576,15605436,15605122,15604229,15604887,15603292,15606153,15603138,15602837,15605892,15604908,15608939,15606232,15606561,15606415,15604745,15606289,15605544,15603183,15605754,15603684,15604681,15603169,15605804,15606642,15601884,15607462,15603597,15605700,15608788,15604117,15606070,15604186,15609283,15604270,15603881,15602843,15602703,15617669,15618722,15603437,15603853,15603808,15604909,15607158,15604856,15605755,15616086,15606262,15635071,15606641,15630445,15607995,15602873,15605338,15611349,15609009,15606634,15604451,15603727,15605645,15603670,15607885,15607149,15602444,15603784,15606548,15602267,15604941,15602457,15607456,15605935,15604345,15601937,15601766,15605685,15605543,15602918,15603029,15602768,15602887,15603780,15622929,15606839,15604062,15605878,15602416,15606377,15603992,15602779,15609513,15601853,15602907,15642385,15607825,15604573,15605232,15603642,15605458,15603768,15609817,15610592,15634532,15605339,15603605,15639406,15602495,15697037,15606672,15604288,15604813,15607541,15646210,15603237,15606352,15607132,15607794,15606618,15604407,15603256,15605805,15603837,15601821,15604676,15603123,15609662,15689743,15606786,15612013,15602366,15601837,15602599,15602708,15601904,15606334,15604517,15604654,15602566,15603329,15612761,15610700,15607429,15604684,15644544,15603562,15604496,15601919,15607766,15602978,15608539,15604397,15607209,15610265,15610777,15620924,15604262,15602298,15607372,15602154,15604287,15658728,15606050,15607938,15602883,15604921,15602105,15602052,15614794,15603610,15602341,15605489,15606507,15635420,15605198,15606022,15605893,15612849,15602452,15613539,15606056,15605870,15604473,15603609,15601930,15602863,15605876,15603001,15652576,15602816,15611778,15605332,15602161,15604476,15603800,15604442,15663410,15602919,15602090,15662909,15656723,15606225,15601741,15606088,15605055,15603831,15604274,15602469,15601950,15603089,15610047,15602692,15604792,15695599,15611037,15607769,15604098,15649293,15614737,15606666,15609604,15605078,15604899,15604895,15604649,15624540,15606104,15603295,15620093,15601822,15613666,15602000,15648969,15604694,15602529,15602652,15606206,15603513,15612459,15606326,15606129,15602553,15604835,15625161,15602534,15602639,15603373,15603372,15648352,15688483,15604099,15610033,15603196,15602726,15602196,15602012,15606602,15606021,15602636,15601876,15613140,15603580,15612500,15611273,15604983,15602511,15625591,15612409,15602407,15604198,15602406,15614312,15616357,15608642,15602276,15602543,15603873,15651571,15617816,15604803,15605979,15604897,15602369,15604930,15608118,15602131,15608968,15603933,15648529,15605007,15610379,15602097,15601867,15603771,15602062,15603087,15604700,15601992,15670803,15602064,15609137,15607435,15607413,15603753,15695627,15604954,15601781,15608900,15605306,15607024,15603674,15602691,15603689,15606694,15602078,15604114,15603805,15606335,15604261,15633417,15602735,15602204,15611556,15604459,15603064,15606753,15602376,15604422,15603748,15618357,15603811,15604536,15603885,15602836,15655696,15604236,15611240,15602443,15604638,15665763,15612115,15603090,15659977,15603103,15606141,15602227,15648557,15636033,15602653,15608309,15601779,15605086,15604524,15602158,15604491,15602659,15602737,15602166,15604583,15605213,15604139,15603117,15603442,15605406,15612436,15611197,15604727,15603553,15603848,15610643,15603177,15605905,15602389,15654143,15604073,15605127,15636339,15601934,15612028,15606607,15604820,15602034,15612068,15602656,15606324,15609701,15605052,15603898,15603340,15602046,15606708,15602850,15615722,15604036,15648324,15602732,15602720,15609596,15612623,15604130,15603484,15602593,15630925,15602554,15601959,15604220,15602834,15612233,15609065,15603721,15602728,15604667,15701573,15630326,15607862,15602033,15604360,15602005,15608759,15605114,15603457,15602442,15602694,15612537,15605279,15654530,15604064,15606544,15602635,15606363,15608979,15603951,15603766,15601932,15610312,15689726,15614867,15601955,15637279,15603978,15602003,15604272,15648680,15613271,15624877,15602730,15601979,15687570,15602483,15605744,15602192,15609606,15606005,15604026,15615046,15603161,15611738,15606375,15605189,15601902,15614899,15610012,15601989,15602127,15609251,15607953,15610742,15604370,15606413,15602672,15602015,15604482,15604800,15603377,15602986,15603997,15603464,15604322,15619763,15602878,15603190,15602905,15647439,15601845,15602665,15605716,15602222,15614583,15636140,15665517,15619679,15637660,15612752,15607279,15610843,15607312,15611261,15604081,15608533,15611547,15609966,15601740,15611421,15609968,15687751,15601998,15603976,15610734,15603943,15608520,15611457,15603436,15605287,15602191,15613119,15602906,15632465,15610706,15602631,15601738,15610406,15605858,15602051,15602445,15602544,15604996,15601865,15606788,15618638,15602112,15603793,15604266,15602803,15606288,15602801,15611013,15602160,15614557,15603152,15607352,15605771,15664290,15664284,15604201,15604743,15612109,15682005,15602831,15602126,15602622,15602953,15602219,15608260,15602085,15602648,15604379,15603052,15605320,15603014,15615592,15603208,15601943,15602431,15606832,15613118,15601735,15606906,15604334,15610191,15604013,15602451,15607249,15604779,15606423,15605747,15606655,15605570,15602988,15611439,15601847,15609675,15603251,15605017,15614711,15663892,15602309,15603474,15604382,15604024,15603333,15602912,15606864,15615473,15614648,15605770,15601888,15606052,15603887,15603227,15604097,15610538,15609555,15607198,15607004,15601980,15609931,15601774,15604376,15604904,15605035,15603125,15607164,15601870,15606606,15603735,15603155,15604291,15602396,15604576,15607506,15602582,15636834,15609881,15637288,15603003,15603865,15607886,15604029,15606532,15602527,15602963,15612647,15605019,15601958,15606138,15609280,15604149,15699786,15602602,15607793,15603970,15605126,15603924,15632930,15612664,15605873,15610746,15607514,15604736,15604017,15606305,15604645,15602299,15602329,15605752,15605872,15616920,15609433,15603789,15605024,15607744,15660708,15601965,15604577,15602833,15613578,15611661,15603952,15605293,15605112,15611606,15602987,15611492,15608595,15603400,15608230,15604037,15636561,15608010,15605251,15603459,15608196,15602923,15608488,15602846,15605356,15603174,15603584,15603026,15603648,15605134,15618466,15608390,15617674,15615347,15616909,15603030,15608930,15603017,15603009,15602698,15602233,15603512,15603233,15603733,15602927,15633562,15604678,15604246,15603281,15604074,15602879,15604962,15638925,15607680,15640010,15605589,15615331,15605488,15603266,15644841,15619560,15603097,15602596,15686844,15607408,15605282,15617692,15668111,15614888,15649300,15603180,15646617,15612443,15602098,15605473,15602777,15602902,15604850,15603896,15603135,15617951,15603115,15603331,15604184,15604330,15638896,15607562,15639468,15615317,15603337,15602921,15603323,15603932,15602793,15636872,15609387,15603091,15621695,15619647,15603344,15603479,15603015,15602827,15636668,15611254,15605909,15639527,15622780,15603051,15605005,15602190,15603315,15615264,15603649,15603543,15606774,15614314,15609385,15612515,15634856,15603495,15602864,15638349,15604463,15603330,15622434,15605507,15604116,15619193,15608483,15603560,15608970,15607635,15604253,15608766,15615928,15605097,15603356,15615305,15603508,15603179,15603132,15635217,15603700,15603585,15602084,15602980,15603519,15605329,15604265,15638365,15603575,15603824,15639452,15605526,15605384,15623800,15603529,15608314,15603734,15605366,15603412,15603507,15602845,15634801,15603505,15603995,15603407,15615874,15618298,15601855,15603496,15607909,15601885,15602381,15636939,15603729,15638674,15604809,15603655,15607905,15641451,15641448,15602521,15605258,15607902,15606024,15607589,15613185,15607891,15608986,15621848,15603392,15603955,15607889,15603556,15638245,15636405,15610421,15603033,15603644,15606889,15605575,15642619,15601906,15605433,15604706,15603427,15601969,15601933,15641458,15603185,15603399,15609015,15602552,15634889,15612220,15608728,15604135,15618548,15614582,15610599,15609566,15609552,15609502,15606625,15605254,15605018,15604276,15604148,15603760,15603568,15603223,15603092,15603049,15603021,15602951,15602772,15603592,15603588,15603586,15601864,15602354,15607088,15602702,15614857,15640741,15671779,15622700,15604763,15614903,15604802,15662751,15605617,15604475,15603486,15606405,15603238,15603209,15608166,15602889,15606113,15636509,15604279,15622821,15622818,15607968,15604295,15613174,15603750,15608916,15603503,15606089,15602909,15602320],"score":624,"text":"Please lead with the location of the position and include the keywords\nREMOTE, INTERNS and/or VISA when the corresponding sort of candidate is welcome.\nWhen remote work is not an option, include ONSITE. If it isn't a household name,\nplease explain what your company does.

Submitters: please only post if you personally are part of the hiring company—no\nrecruiting firms or job boards. One post per company please.

Readers: please only email submitters if you personally are interested in the\njob—no recruiters or sales calls.

You can also use kristopolous' console script to search the thread:\nhttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10313519.","time":1509548473,"title":"Ask HN: Who is hiring? (November 2017)","type":"story"}],[14444914,{"by":"darwhy","descendants":293,"id":14444914,"kids":[14445805,14445474,14446144,14445156,14445163,14445119,14446027,14445946,14445443,14445455,14448471,14446139,14446407,14455996,14445229,14445386,14451371,14445930,14445312,14445379,14445534,14445584,14445661,14447534,14450089,14445978,14445887,14445376,14445883,14445996,14446310,14445924,14446701,14447296,14446760,14447615,14445550,14447315,14447127,14484784,14445324,14445428,14445934,14445166,14445851,14446226,14445388,14445748],"score":653,"time":1496148666,"title":"How to Improve a Legacy Codebase","type":"story","url":"http://jacquesmattheij.com/improving-a-legacy-codebase"}],[11202954,{"by":"whoishiring","descendants":814,"id":11202954,"kids":[11206584,11203354,11205231,11203586,11203625,11203552,11203697,11203258,11205858,11203290,11204332,11204939,11203078,11203939,11203169,11203658,11203608,11203294,11204832,11204112,11203639,11204860,11203061,11204287,11207473,11203708,11203497,11205007,11204664,11205138,11203709,11205150,11203743,11203737,11203268,11203749,11203016,11205801,11205699,11203051,11204590,11203194,11206747,11209262,11210375,11203725,11204102,11203744,11203217,11205296,11204922,11203524,11207894,11203008,11203768,11205052,11204110,11204403,11203426,11203036,11203467,11205014,11203963,11206267,11203507,11206952,11205876,11205553,11204155,11203125,11203704,11203367,11203441,11204558,11204061,11203569,11206719,11203388,11206407,11203410,11203267,11215516,11288191,11203455,11204232,11203977,11204594,11204779,11204015,11208042,11204207,11203504,11203584,11204887,11206053,11206353,11204319,11205329,11204214,11203434,11205303,11207517,11208259,11203373,11207338,11203236,11203209,11205402,11203350,11204902,11206058,11263046,11205415,11203993,11227761,11204635,11204220,11207926,11203295,11205523,11203018,11204024,11207422,11206779,11204124,11208440,11206625,11203107,11204057,11204993,11203556,11203750,11206084,11207242,11208202,11204054,11203065,11204877,11203273,11204561,11204965,11203112,11206533,11203014,11205980,11203986,11204698,11205108,11244661,11204675,11204471,11203494,11203093,11204522,11205352,11209783,11206752,11203498,11244538,11205120,11204537,11203726,11204686,11203776,11205519,11203108,11204883,11211395,11224546,11203351,11203299,11204247,11240945,11205213,11204628,11203989,11207181,11219704,11204598,11204744,11215329,11203863,11204478,11203587,11203889,11255493,11204526,11203581,11212687,11203505,11207944,11205928,11205493,11203832,11215092,11203105,11206090,11205740,11212208,11205707,11206971,11205919,11206093,11219610,11224481,11205495,11204376,11203316,11205690,11239892,11206516,11203798,11250264,11212636,11206822,11226218,11205065,11204189,11212640,11203619,11209528,11273919,11217771,11206222,11203895,11203179,11205205,11203145,11205616,11217654,11206946,11259659,11203029,11203154,11205337,11209846,11206828,11204470,11204097,11203408,11204139,11214922,11204161,11207562,11206515,11205414,11206607,11240340,11206840,11203206,11204135,11204198,11203638,11203836,11205109,11203478,11215096,11206167,11203876,11208005,11220481,11207806,11211451,11205328,11204822,11203193,11204583,11203644,11219678,11212400,11206865,11203557,11205944,11205571,11204566,11204451,11204444,11210225,11204315,11206696,11203088,11204065,11204355,11208318,11205412,11210107,11203712,11208325,11205221,11204679,11203329,11207460,11205173,11202973,11266616,11204826,11203782,11205465,11206922,11206905,11203378,11204414,11205742,11208327,11205710,11204197,11205596,11205702,11204763,11203515,11212473,11219498,11219509,11205324,11204218,11205406,11204142,11207647,11246369,11204291,11203117,11230009,11240612,11224740,11204775,11206990,11202965,11238409,11203957,11203369,11204371,11240677,11206953,11218642,11204964,11206214,11265471,11205113,11206206,11205678,11203837,11205853,11205068,11203966,11211040,11204890,11206987,11207883,11204684,11207510,11204650,11204720,11223997,11211636,11204365,11261058,11204811,11207735,11206669,11206441,11204285,11254920,11205904,11205153,11212271,11206252,11204311,11204833,11227320,11203676,11256446,11213596,11206042,11205816,11207845,11211500,11206310,11203907,11212424,11208418,11203121,11212740,11205119,11256013,11207960,11208019,11205379,11211736,11205196,11203211,11203562,11206841,11206637,11205424,11205759,11204431,11207491,11238595,11204818,11204682,11206139,11205478,11203238,11207114,11210091,11206479,11205207,11204605,11205510,11213236,11205456,11209640,11207677,11203475,11204631,11204424,11204080,11253824,11206296,11203755,11205016,11203690,11226208,11203911,11206806,11205280,11226778,11204227,11203790,11203303,11203187,11203575,11207571,11206506,11205285,11210018,11223747,11216940,11206510,11205666,11208682,11287686,11206641,11204612,11224694,11255823,11204326,11220274,11206359,11214179,11207094,11203529,11283910,11203495,11204050,11204626,11204545,11212466,11203355,11238959,11206956,11203610,11209922,11207060,11204078,11203873,11204271,11220300,11215352,11218576,11204958,11204496,11203940,11205825,11237018,11204557,11205512,11203360,11206849,11205598,11203947,11213289,11206687,11226243,11204692,11206136,11220283,11205195,11203573,11203470,11203988,11207285,11208636,11209916,11207878,11203931,11204011,11203959,11208404,11205382,11204302,11205865,11204195,11203898,11224166,11203142,11208866,11204647,11219495,11208382,11203519,11204095,11204105,11207215,11203965,11207665,11204349,11210308,11212461,11203997,11204666,11204685,11203043,11204264,11215281,11207308,11207243,11207028,11204450,11203579,11203321,11204006,11205114,11204416,11205701,11204770,11207303,11205942,11209175,11204446,11203386,11207683,11205304,11207687,11204224,11207890,11204239,11207791,11204508,11205770,11204683,11211234,11209160,11203216,11204066,11204951,11206027,11205826,11208195,11204870,11207480,11207777,11218253,11212491,11207607,11204204,11203656,11203752,11223053,11205814,11204584,11204157,11207122,11203049,11206705,11247964,11219840,11207207,11215729,11203543,11203334,11204802,11204690,11204929,11204151,11282651,11215881,11205225,11203364,11209111,11203508,11207379,11206170,11214516,11203620,11208658,11206599,11204321,11204476,11210621,11203407,11204490,11206085,11203416,11226835,11205398,11203477,11203509,11203819,11205305,11207509,11222117,11204274,11203719,11204803,11204670,11210331,11203702,11204475,11203985,11207043,11203840,11208544,11205056,11204769,11203839,11207913,11226127,11213667,11209379,11203647,11206095,11260220,11203908,11203935,11203022,11214273,11203996,11203912,11203140,11204230,11264948,11204458,11204901,11207539,11206663,11206097,11203588,11204796,11203732,11205726,11203390,11205363,11204175,11204325,11204548,11205683,11203699,11205715,11204108,11206168,11205658,11203722,11203309,11204632,11204750,11203672,11203055,11202961,11206041,11206037,11283143,11209671,11207697,11206776,11205933,11205548,11204554,11204519,11204156,11203995,11203969,11203603,11203172,11203155,11202972,11204673,11204322,11204687,11250266,11205749,11205210,11205217,11204081,11279138,11207380,11213816,11213697,11203841,11204234,11213227,11213642,11252087,11208024,11204301,11204260,11203987,11203387,11203812,11203602,11203595,11203540],"score":488,"text":"Please lead with the location of the position and include the keywords\nREMOTE, INTERNS and/or VISA when the corresponding sort of candidate is welcome.\nWhen remote work is not an option, please include ONSITE.

Submitters: please only post if you personally are part of the hiring company—no\nrecruiting firms or job boards.

Readers: please only email submitters if you personally are interested in the\njob—no recruiters or sales calls.

You can also use kristopolous' nifty console script to search the thread:\nhttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10313519.","time":1456844448,"title":"Ask HN: Who is hiring? (March 2016)","type":"story"}],[8632043,{"by":"craigkerstiens","descendants":59,"id":8632043,"kids":[8632434,8632736,8632300,8635083,8634599,8632608,8632539,8632424,8634736,8632283,8633467,8635325,8634993,8633762,8645086,8635236,8632193,8632587,8632856,8632547,8634297,8635605,8635619,8632758,8632958,8633248],"score":205,"time":1416424968,"title":"Queues Don't Fix Overload","type":"story","url":"http://ferd.ca/queues-don-t-fix-overload.html"}]]

user:	stephenwilcock
created:	August 29, 2014
karma:	7